Best beaches in Windermere Island

2 ranked beaches in Windermere Island, Central Eleuthera

Ranked by the OnlyBeaches Index (OBI) — a 1-10 score blending water purity, conditions, crowd levels and vibe. Updated every 30 minutes.

All beaches in Windermere Island

1
Windermere Island Atlantic Beach
A quieter Atlantic-side Windermere beach identity that should stay separate from the main island beach.
7.0
2
Windermere Island Beach
The key beach identity for Windermere Island and an important luxury/island beach in this region.
7.0

What makes Windermere Island's beaches stand out?

Windermere Island sits in Central Eleuthera, Bahamas and is home to 2 ranked beaches on OnlyBeaches. Every beach here is scored by the OnlyBeaches Index — a 1-10 metric blending water purity, live conditions (waves, water temperature, wind), crowd intelligence and vibe.

Whether you're after the highest-scoring beach in Windermere Island or a quieter hidden cove, the list above is refreshed every 30 minutes using live Stormglass and OpenWeather data.