Polishing the menu…

Discover

Explore beaches
All beaches
Plan a trip

Editorial

Rankings
Best Beaches 2026
Blue Flag beaches
Journal
Events

Account

Saved
Profile
Sign in
List my business

Home
Map
Saved
Profile

Brooklyn Pizzeria near Bay St. Louis, USA | OnlyBeaches | OnlyBeaches

Should I Go?Explore Beaches Plan Rankings Events Report 2026 Blue Flag Journal

Home
/
Restaurants
/
USA
/
Bay St. Louis
/
Brooklyn Pizzeria

Tagged inPizza

Brooklyn Pizzeria

restaurant Unclaimed$ Open now

Brooklyn Pizzeria

AUTHENTIC NEW YORK PIZZA, MISSISSIPPI STYLE!

4.5·659 reviews

295 U.S. 90, Bay St. Louis, Bay St. Louis, USA

Overview
Amenities
Reviews
Hours
Location
Nearby

Highlights

Experience a true taste of Brooklyn right in the heart of Bay St. Louis, offering classic New York-style pizzas with a friendly Southern twist.
Conveniently located, it's the perfect spot to grab a slice after exploring the charming shops and galleries along Bay St. Louis's historic streets.
Enjoy generous portions and fresh ingredients, ensuring every pizza, pasta, and sub delivers on authentic flavor and satisfaction.
A beloved community staple, this pizzeria consistently earns high ratings for its delicious food, welcoming atmosphere, and excellent service.

Amenities & vibes

WALKABLELOCAL FAVORITECASUAL DINING

Best price guarantee

We price match for you

Free cancellation

Up to 24 hours before

Secure booking

Your data is protected

Local support

We're here to help

670m away to beach

FAMILY FRIENDLY

TAKEOUT AVAILABLE

OUTDOOR SEATING

Featured dishes

The Brooklyn Bridge Pizza

A classic New York-style large pie topped with rich marinara, generous mozzarella, and your choice of premium pepperoni or savory Italian sausage.

$22

Grandma's Square Pie

A thick, square-cut pizza featuring a crispy crust, sweet San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and a hint of basil, baked to perfection.

$24

Bay St. Louis Stromboli

A rolled masterpiece filled with ham, pepperoni, mozzarella, and a side of their homemade marinara, perfect for a hearty meal.

$14

Manhattan Meatball Sub

Toasted hero bread loaded with tender, house-made meatballs, melted provolone cheese, and a generous slathering of their signature red sauce.

$13

Similar Restaurants nearby

Community Bank

5.0(5)855m away

Sycamore House | French

4.5(185)1.3km away

Barracuda Taco Stand

4.4(106)1.3km away

About this place

Brooklyn Pizzeria

4.5· 659 reviews

Claim this listing

Contact

295 U.S. 90, Bay St. Louis

Beach access

670m away

to the nearest beach

Nearby beaches

Bay St. Louis Beach668m away
Washington Street Beach1.2km away
Lakeshore Beach1.4km away

Location

295 U.S. 90, Bay St. Louis, Bay St. Louis, USA

Open in Google Maps